Casey Mize
"The No. 1 pick who spent his first professional summer pitching to no one at all."
Casey Mize made his major-league debut in a stadium with no spectators — the entire 2020 season was played in empty ballparks because of the pandemic, meaning the highest-profile draft pick in Tigers history threw his first big-league pitch in front of cardboard cutouts, not people.
Mize is one of the clearest data points in Detroit's long rebuild: the No. 1 overall pick whose path from can't-miss prospect to Tommy John recovery to rotation regular mirrors the Tigers' own arc from rebuilding to contending.
The 'former No. 1 pick' label tends to freeze a player's story at draft night, as if everything after is either fulfillment or failure — it flattens the multi-year, unglamorous process of surgery and rehab that most top picks actually go through before anyone calls them established.
In the U.S. amateur draft, there is no lottery: the worst team in baseball simply gets the first pick, live, on national television, with the player's name read aloud by the league commissioner in front of cameras — a single, unrepeatable moment of exposure very different from Japan's NPB draft, which uses a lottery specifically to prevent any one team, or any one prospect, from being handed that kind of certainty.
When broadcasters say a player was the '#1 overall pick,' they're describing not just talent evaluation but a negotiated signing bonus tied to a league-wide bonus pool — the slot itself comes with a specific dollar figure attached before the player throws a single professional pitch, which is why draft position and contract value get discussed in the same breath.
Casey Mize, a right-handed pitcher from Springville, was the first overall selection in the 2018 MLB Draft by the Detroit Tigers. He debuted on August 19, 2020, during a pandemic-altered season played without fans, and has since navigated Tommy John surgery and a long rehabilitation — a career defined less by a single moment than by the slow, public work of coming back.
| Year | Team | G | W–L | ERA | IP | SO | WHIP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | DET | 14 | 4–6 | 2.79 | 77.1 | 77 | 1.00 |
| 2025 | DET | 28 | 14–6 | 3.87 | 149.0 | 139 | 1.27 |
| 2024 | DET | 22 | 2–6 | 4.49 | 102.1 | 78 | 1.47 |
| Career | — | 103 | 27–31 | 3.98 | 517.1 | 442 | 1.24 |
Source: MLB Stats API · regular season
An Empty Ballpark
On August 19, 2020, Casey Mize threw his first pitch in a major-league game. There was no crowd noise, no ushers, no line at the concession stand — just the sound of the ball hitting the mitt, echoing through a stadium emptied by pandemic protocol. That detail, easy to forget now, says something about the strange circumstances under which some of the decade's most anticipated debuts actually happened: the 2020 season was played entirely without fans in the stands, a fact so normalized at the time that it's rarely mentioned in retrospectives, but one that shaped the atmosphere of Mize's entrance into the major leagues in a way no scouting report could have predicted.
First Overall
Mize was selected first overall in the 2018 MLB Draft by the Detroit Tigers, a widely documented fact that placed him, at 21, at the center of a franchise rebuild before he had thrown a single professional pitch. Being drafted first overall in American baseball is not a matter of chance — there is no lottery, no weighted odds. The worst team in baseball simply picks first, and that team's decision becomes an immediate, public bet on one person's right arm. For a franchise that lost 114 games the year it selected him, Mize's name carried the weight of a turnaround plan before he ever set foot on a big-league mound.
Unlike systems that use a lottery to distribute the top selection among multiple losing teams, Major League Baseball's draft order is set purely by the previous season's standings — the team with the worst record picks first, full stop. This is why a single draft-night selection, like Mize's in 2018, gets discussed for years afterward as a defining organizational decision rather than a matter of luck.
The Rebuild Within the Rebuild
Mize's professional path took a detour that is itself part of the story: he underwent Tommy John surgery, the reconstructive elbow procedure that has become almost a rite of passage for modern pitchers, sidelining him for a significant stretch. The surgery and the year-plus rehabilitation that follows it are, by now, so common in professional baseball that they've developed their own cultural shorthand — a recognized, almost expected detour rather than a career-ending event. What's less visible to casual observers is how much of a pitcher's early career can be consumed by this cycle: throw, get hurt, rebuild the arm, return, and try to pick up exactly where a very different, younger version of yourself left off.
Right-Handed, Unhurried
At 6-foot-3 and 212 pounds, Mize throws and bats right-handed — the basic physical facts of a pitcher built to work deep into games rather than overpower hitters with pure velocity alone. Wearing No. 12 for Detroit, he occupies a rotation spot that, for a former No. 1 pick, carries a particular kind of scrutiny: every start is read against the promise of draft night, whether or not that comparison is fair. The measure of his career, at this point, is less about recapturing a singular moment of hype and more about the accumulation of ordinary, healthy starts — the unglamorous proof that the arm held up.
Official MLB Shop and Amazon links matched to Casey Mize and the Detroit Tigers.
Casey Mize gear at the official MLB ShopThis profile was written by AI (Claude Sonnet) using publicly available sources. Interpretations and cultural notes are AI-generated and may not reflect the views of the player, their team, or MLB. This page contains affiliate links.